Craftsman vs DeWalt: Which is Better? (2024 Guide)

I’ve used just about every power tool brand over the years and there’s certainly some big differences between them.

Two popular brands, Craftsman and DeWalt, often get compared – but which is better?

In this Craftsman vs DeWalt comparison, I’ll help you decide which brand is best for your need. Let’s get into it!

Craftsman vs DeWalt Comparion

Tool Quality and Durability

Both Craftsman and DeWalt tools are very durable and offer great quality. But they aren’t exactly the same.

Let’s start with Craftsman. I have an affectionate nostalgia for the brand, which dates back to my early days in the workshop with my father.

Craftsman tools have always delivered a good blend of quality and affordability. They are sturdy, reliable, and have a good overall feel.

I’ve owned Craftsman wrenches that have lasted me years without any wear and tear, proving their mettle against time and heavy use. Their hand tools, in particular, have always been stellar with a lifetime warranty that speaks volumes about their durability.

On the other hand, we have DeWalt, a brand synonymous with professional-grade tools.

Using a DeWalt tool, you can feel the higher quality in its build and performance. Their power tools, especially, are top-notch and hard to rival.

I’ve seen DeWalt drills handle tasks that have made other brands struggle. The robustness and long-lasting performance of DeWalt tools make them a favorite among professionals, including myself.

Overall, in terms of quality and durability, DeWalt is the best here.

Design and Performance

Having used Craftsman and DeWalt tools for years, I’ve come to appreciate the unique aspects of their design and performance. Each brand caters to different user profiles, and their designs reflect this.

With Craftsman, their tools are designed with the everyday user in mind.

Their ergonomic designs are generally straightforward and user-friendly. You’ll find tools with comfortable grips that reduce strain, especially for long-term projects. The design simplicity makes Craftsman tools great for DIY enthusiasts and homeowners. In terms of performance, Craftsman tools are reliable and get the job done. While they may not always have the power or endurance of a professional-grade tool like DeWalt, they are more than adequate for general use.

On the other hand, DeWalt’s design philosophy seems to prioritize function and robustness, catering more towards the professional market.

Their tools are often heavier, a result of the more durable materials used in their construction. This does mean they can be bulkier and may feel overbuilt for casual users. However, the rugged design ensures they can endure harsh job site conditions.

Performance-wise, DeWalt tools tend to have more power and run time, especially their cordless range. They are designed for intensive use, and this shows in their ability to handle more demanding tasks. DeWalt’s power tools often deliver high torque and speeds, which can make a significant difference when working with tougher materials.

Product Lines and Offerings

Craftsman has a wide range of product offerings that covers nearly every category of hand and power tools.

This includes everything from wrenches and socket sets to power drills and saws, and even extends to larger equipment like lawn mowers and snow blowers.

They also have an impressive selection of tool storage solutions, such as tool chests and cabinets. Craftsman’s product line is especially appealing to those who need a one-stop-shop for their tool needs, be it for home improvement tasks or for more specialized projects.

Craftsman Tools

• Hand tools such as screwdrivers, hammers, wrenches, and pliers
• Power tools including drills, saws, and sanders
• Outdoor tools and equipment like lawnmowers, trimmers, and leaf blowers
• Tool storage solutions like tool chests, tool cabinets, and tool bags
• A range of automotive tools including jacks, wrenches, and mechanic tool sets
• Bench tools, including table saws, bench grinders, and drill presses
• A range of cordless tools in their V20 system

DeWalt’s offerings, while also extensive, lean more towards the professional side of the spectrum.

They have an exceptional range of power tools including drills, saws, grinders, and more. Their line-up of cordless tools, powered by their 20V MAX and FLEXVOLT battery systems, is particularly noteworthy.

DeWalt also offers a range of jobsite equipment like radios, fans, lights, and even heated jackets. The brand excels in creating a cohesive ecosystem where their batteries are interchangeable across a wide array of their tools. This makes DeWalt a favored choice among professionals who need reliable, high-performing tools that can handle heavy-duty tasks.

DeWalt Tools

• Professional-grade power tools like drills, grinders, circular saws, and planers
• Cordless tools in their 20V MAX and FLEXVOLT systems, offering great interoperability
• Hand tools including hammers, screwdrivers, pliers, and multi-tools
• Jobsite storage solutions and tool storage
• Laser levels and other construction measurement tools
• Jobsite accessories such as radios, lights, and heated jackets
• Outdoor power equipment like leaf blowers, chainsaws, and string trimmers
• Benchtop tools including table saws, miter saws, and planers

While there are areas of overlap, each brand shines in different respects.

Craftsman has a well-rounded product line that makes it suitable for a broad array of users, from homeowners to professionals.

DeWalt’s line-up, while also versatile, is geared towards professionals and those who demand top-tier performance from their tools.

So, your choice between the two would depend largely on your specific tool requirements and the nature of the tasks you typically undertake.

Warranty and Repair Services

If you’re going to spend a decent amount of money on your tools, finding a brand with a solid warranty to back them up is essential.

Craftsman is well known for its warranty service, particularly for their hand tools.

Many of their hand tools come with a lifetime warranty, which has been a hallmark of the brand for decades. This essentially means that if a tool fails due to a defect in material or workmanship, Craftsman will replace it for free.

For power tools, the warranty period is typically one year from the date of purchase. However, it’s important to check the specific warranty conditions for each tool, as there can be exceptions.

On the other hand, DeWalt offers a limited warranty for their power tools, typically for a period of three years from the date of purchase.

This covers defects in material or workmanship and offers a free repair service during this period. Additionally, DeWalt provides a one-year free service contract, where they will maintain the tool and replace worn parts caused by normal use, for free. There’s also a 90-day money-back guarantee if you’re not satisfied with the tool. For some specific tools, a different warranty may apply, so it’s crucial to check the warranty details.

In terms of repair services, both Craftsman and DeWalt have service centers across the country.

However, in my experience, the turnaround time can vary depending on the location and the nature of the repair. Both brands also offer the option to order replacement parts for self-repair for some tools, which can be convenient.

Overall, DeWalt tends to offer a slightly better warranty on their products.

Pricing and Budget

When it comes to pricing, Craftsman is no doubt the stronger option here.

Craftsman offers a broad range of tools that are reasonably priced, making them an attractive choice for hobbyists, DIY enthusiasts, and homeowners. They provide solid functionality and durability for their cost, delivering good value for the average user who might not need top-tier professional tools.

On the other side, DeWalt tools were often priced higher than their Craftsman counterparts. The reason for this price difference was the professional-grade quality and performance that DeWalt offered. Their tools are designed to handle tougher, more demanding tasks and are built to last, even in rugged job site conditions.

While the upfront cost might be higher, DeWalt’s durability and performance could provide long-term value, especially for professionals who use their tools extensively.

That said, prices can vary significantly depending on the specific tool, its features, and where you purchase it.

It’s also worth noting that while Craftsman’s lower prices may be attractive for casual users, DeWalt’s higher performance might justify the extra investment for heavy users. As always, the best choice depends on your specific needs, budget, and how intensively you plan to use the tool.

DeWalt vs Craftsman Cordless Tool Comparison

When it comes to cordless power tools, both brands offer a wide array of products for anyone.

Craftsman’s cordless tools are a part of their V20 Cordless System.

This includes a wide variety of tools, from drills and impact drivers to saws and even lawn equipment, all powered by the same 20V battery platform. The interoperability of the batteries across the range is a significant advantage, making it convenient to switch between tools.

In terms of performance, Craftsman cordless tools are generally adequate for a wide range of tasks around the home or for light professional use. The battery life is reasonable, and the power output is good for the price point.

DeWalt’s cordless tools, on the other hand, belong to their 20V MAX and FLEXVOLT systems.

Their cordless line is extensive and known for its robust performance. These tools are designed to handle professional-grade workloads.

Their drills, for example, often deliver higher torque than Craftsman equivalents, allowing them to handle tougher tasks more efficiently. DeWalt’s FLEXVOLT system is particularly innovative, offering batteries that can automatically change voltage when you switch tools. This means you can use the same battery for both 20V MAX and 60V MAX tools, providing remarkable versatility.

In terms of durability, DeWalt cordless tools generally have a sturdier build, designed to withstand rough job site conditions. Craftsman tools are also reliable, but they may not endure heavy-duty tasks as well as DeWalt’s line does.

When comparing price, DeWalt’s cordless tools are typically more expensive than Craftsman’s, reflecting the higher performance and build quality. However, Craftsman offers excellent value for the money, especially for those who do not require top-tier professional-grade tools.

Check out this DeWalt review for more details!

Craftsman vs DeWalt Table Saw

Craftsman table saws are generally designed with the homeowner and DIY enthusiast in mind. They offer good performance for a variety of tasks, from ripping boards to crafting precise joinery.

Most Craftsman table saws feature a cast aluminum table, built-in storage, and a portable design for easy transport. They provide decent power for most tasks, and their user-friendly features make them a good choice for users who want a reliable table saw without a hefty price tag.

DeWalt table saws, on the other hand, are often aimed at professionals and serious woodworkers. They are known for their robust build, high power, and precision.

Many DeWalt table saws are portable, with a compact design for easy transport to and from job sites. Notable features include rack and pinion fence systems for fast, accurate fence adjustments, and powerful motors that can handle hardwoods and pressure-treated lumber with ease. While DeWalt table saws are typically more expensive than Craftsman models, they deliver professional-grade performance.

Final Verdict: Which Tools Are Better?

In my years of experience using both brands of tools, I can confidently say that the DeWalt brand makes better, more durable tools.

However, they do come at a higher price.

So if you’re looking for high quality tools at a great price, I’d recommend Craftsman power tools.

History of Craftsman Tools

Craftsman started its journey in 1927 when it was registered as a trademark by Sears, an American department store.

The Craftsman brand became renowned for its quality and durability, particularly in its line of hand tools. Their products were marketed towards everyday consumers and professionals alike. Over the years, Craftsman’s reputation grew, and it became one of the most recognized tool brands in the United States.

However, in 2017, Sears sold the brand to Stanley Black & Decker due to financial troubles. Since then, Stanley Black & Decker has been working to revitalize the Craftsman brand and expand its distribution outside of Sears.

History of DeWalt Tools

On the other hand, DeWalt has its roots in the early 20th century.

The brand was started by Raymond E. DeWalt, the inventor of the radial arm saw, in 1924. This saw revolutionized carpentry and set a high standard for the quality and innovation that would become synonymous with the DeWalt name.

In 1947, DeWalt was reorganized and reincorporated as DeWalt Inc. After years of growth, it was acquired by Black & Decker in 1960. However, it wasn’t until the early ’90s that the modern version of DeWalt we know today really took shape, when Black & Decker rebranded their professional-quality tools under the DeWalt name. Since then, DeWalt has become a major player in the market for professional-grade tools, with a reputation for robustness and high performance.

FAQs

How do Craftsman tools compare to DeWalt in terms of quality?

Craftsman tools are generally reliable and of good quality, suitable for everyday use and lighter professional tasks. DeWalt tools, aimed more at the professional market, often offer higher quality in terms of materials and construction, enabling them to handle more demanding jobs. However, this is reflected in a higher price point compared to Craftsman.

Do Craftsman and DeWalt use the same battery types?

Craftsman and DeWalt do not use the same battery types. Craftsman cordless tools utilize the V20 battery system, while DeWalt uses the 20V MAX and FLEXVOLT systems. These batteries are not interchangeable between the brands.

Are Craftsman tools as durable as DeWalt’s?

Craftsman tools are durable and can last for years with proper care, especially their hand tools, which are often backed by a lifetime warranty. However, DeWalt tools, designed for professional use, generally exhibit superior durability under heavy-duty use and rugged job site conditions.

Final Thoughts

Overall, both Craftsman power tools and DeWalt power tools offer amazing products that I’ve used for years.

However, I’d give DeWalt the edge for numerous reasons. I’ve used my DeWalt cordless tools under a wide range of conditions and they always outperform Craftsman tools.

That said, when it comes to hand tools, Craftsman offers great products at a lower price.

Ultimately, if you’re searching for the best of the best – go with DeWalt. But if you want great products at a lower price – you can’t beat Craftsman.